Mistake of judgment (911/ detainees; pro Gitmo camp)
There is a repeated line out in the web from people who are against bringing the 9/11 terrorists to trial in New York. The stand that they tend to take is that since the terrorists were caught in Pakistan, they should be tried over in Pakistan rather than in the United States of America.
Look, there would be a lot of nuts that would just oppose this measure since President Obama Obama suggested it. These are the far right. The far left would simply go ga-ga over this rule and would like it the same manner that the far right hates it. To these people, these article is not for you! This is for the saner readers.
That being said, I think it is very ridiculous that these people think like that! Come on! Where in the world have they been living? Crime is always punished at the state/country it happened. It is something that happens all over the world.
For example, if someone murders someone in Washington but was caught across the border at British Columbia, Canada, something that happens once in a while, the Canadians do not hear his/ her trial in Canada. They would extradite that person to Washington and then, criminal proceedings would begin. This also happens state to state within our nation unless, it falls under the jurisdiction of the FBI (bank robbery, crimes in multiple states, or across state lines etc) . It rightfully happens all the time!
Yes some of you would point out that Pakistan has also have suffered atrocities at the hands of Al Qaeda. However, no ne at that time, suffered a higher casualty than America did on 9/11. We lost about 3000 lives that day, something that all other countries have not suffered.
E.g. If a person killed 10 people in Washington and was caught in British Columbia where he committed robbery, the Canadians would usually extradite that person to the Washington. The only exceptions would be if they have got some issues with our laws, or some extreme cases where Canada is affected. The Pakistanis have got no excuses here.
Some people mention about how the Japanese were tried in Japan in World War two and not in the United States where they destroyed Pearl Harbor. The difference in that situation and this is, that that was a war! This is not a war. President Bush’s “war on terror” slogan is no longer used. It is now global contingency operations. It is not one state attacking another, it is criminals against the state.
I would also like to reiterate the need to try these people on our land. It would be the justice that we deserved. The Iraqis saw Saddam Hussein being hung. I think America should have her day and see that Khalid Sheik Muhammad and company be hung too. That would be justice!
I also would like to stress that there should not be the “abolishment” of the death penalty in this case. Keeping prisoners forever would only lead to future hijackings or kidnappings where the release of these prisoners would be sought as ransom. It is something that has been used by the militants before, and would be used again in the future.
We in ST would also like to remind readers that tomorrow is the anniversary of the bombing of Pearl Harbor.
Related articles by Zemanta
- Terp spy ring working at Gitmo? (tech.bl0x.info)
- Afghanistan Escalation: Why Not Send 30,000 Troops to Somalia? (emptywheel.firedoglake.com)
- Afghanistan: The Missing Strategy (blogs.nybooks.com)
- The ‘Bright Line Rule’: New Papers Detail FBI, CIA Wrangle Over Torture (huffingtonpost.com)
- Details on interrogations emerge (msnbc.msn.com)
- New papers detail FBI, CIA wrangle over detainees (seattletimes.nwsource.com)
- Political Culture: Of Afghanistan, and a Girl from Nantucket (popdose.com)
- Obama’s West Point Speech: Did He Convince You? (alan.com)
- Libya’s Gadhafi ridicules UN (thestar.com)
- The logical core of Matthew Hoh’s resignation letter (jamesfallows.theatlantic.com)
- “Alexa Ray Joel Hospitalized; Drug Overdose Rumored” and related posts (thehollywoodgossip.com)
- “Mary Glasspool, the First Lesbian US Bishop” and related posts (gayrights.change.org)
- “Sarah Palin, Barney Frank and the Gridiron Club” and related posts (swampland.blogs.time.com)
- “SEC Championship Game 2009: Florida Vs. Alabama” and related posts (huffingtonpost.com)
- “Greg Oden done for the season” and related posts (sportsfilter.com)


