Why Howard Dean is right
We have not talked about health care for a while on this site. But this I cannot ignore. We have said it for a long time and this time I am being echoed by Governor (Dr.) Howard Dean months later : No public option; Kill the Bill!
In a segment with the ever so boring Dylan Ratigan, Governor Howard Dean basically threatened to stop sending in money to the respective Democratic committees in Congress if they do not have a bill in it that has a public option.
Looking back, we know that not nominating him is the biggest mistake that the Democrats ever made. They overlooked a governor that is a proven success and a person that is well informed in 2004, and they picked a long-jaw douche-bag named Senator John Kerry. So not only are the politicians pathetic, their far left voting base in the primaries are pathetic too.
Coming back to health care, I stress that this is the most important part of health care reform : the public option. The biggest problem with the health care cost in our country is cost. That should be the primary objective. And yet, our politicians came up with just one solution to curb costs : public option. (For Republican readers, I would explain in paragraphs below why their idea of buying across state lines would not work.)
Without the public option, there would be a mandate for the public to have health insurance to drive up demand and there is no other counter measure to keep the cost down. Therefore, we are literally throwing our money to the insurance companies with the Bill.
With the public option, there would be pressure to keep the price of the insurance down. If the insurance companies charge us too much, people would switch their plans to the public option which is non profit. It is not very difficult to understand the public option actually.
The Republican proposal of allowing customers to buy across state lines would not work. For it to work, there need to be national rules and guidelines. For example, in football, the rules in Saint Louis is the same as that in Dallas. If you cannot spit at the referee in Dallas, you cannot do it anywhere else.
The rules need to be the same, else you would have all the companies flocking to the state with the lowest amount of regulation. That is the case for the Credit Card companies.
So why can’t there be a national rule: The tenth amendment which guarantees states rights. With that, the federal government cannot force local governments to conform with other states on these issues. Even if our politicians want it, it would be very tricky. I also do not want it to go down that path as I think states rights are very important in our country.
A way around the Republican proposal is the idea that we in ST put up months ago. Allow the foreigners to flood the market. If the Japanese can make cars here, they can also sell their insurance, which is much more cheaper than ours, here. If Indian companies can create for us computer programs, they should also sell their insurances over here. Then let the competition begin!
Though, I hate it when politicians make threats when they can, in this case I am with Governor Dean. The Democrats should not receive any party donations if they cannot fulfill what the people want. A health care bill without the public option would wreck our country and make our lives much tougher than it already is.
Related articles by Zemanta
- Health Care?s Option Play (blogs.wsj.com)
- On “boycotts” (dailykos.com)
- Let’s Not Lose Sight of the Goals (thehealthcareblog.com)
- Will the Cancer-Screening Report Change Health Care? (swampland.blogs.time.com)
- Senate Health Bill Draws Fire on Both Sides of Aisle (nytimes.com)
- News Analysis: Democrats See a Positive in a Bad Economy (nytimes.com)
- Battling Pelosicare (michellemalkin.com)
- NYT: Medical debt spurs more bankruptcies (msnbc.msn.com)
- What Part of Even One American Needlessly Dying to Make One Rich American Richer Is Acceptable? (iflizwerequeen.com)
- Strassel: Help Wanted (online.wsj.com)
- “Donny Osmond Wins Dancing With the Stars” and related posts (x17online.com)
- “Amazon announces better battery life and native PDF support for the Kindle” and related posts (crunchgear.com)
- “Happy 150th Birthday to The Origin of The Species” and related posts (palaeoblog.blogspot.com)
- “Kentucky Census Worker Committed Suicide, Investigators Say” and related posts (huffingtonpost.com)
- “McClatchy: Obama to Order 34,000 More to Afghanistan” and related posts (feeds.dailykos.com)





